jinstall wrote:
I have looked at the 17" and nothing really strikes my fancy. Trying to find a plain jane 5 spoke rim that is easy to maintain, is difficult at the least. OEM KJ with 16" wheels have 235/70/16 H rated tires.
I have driven and I mean really driven several ML (270 and 400CDi) and one X5 (4.4) and I like the Libby better for handling, yes I said handling. The X5 is good for the Autobahn and thats it. Plus it is not avalible in the US with a 3.0D. The MK 270CDi is a pig and wouldn't pass itself in a tornado. The ML400CDi has great power and is a hoot to drive, no towing capacity, and it's fat @$#% will come around on it in a heartbeat when pushed. Thank goodness for ESC on both. I really like the solid rear in the Libby. Even with sidwallflex it still stays glued and trust me when I say I have pushed it to the max several times. Rainy days are my favorite, the ESC light comes on alot on those days. Do I rock crawl with the KJ, no. Do I need 4x4 yes. Do I get in the KJ with muddy stuff and the dog all wet and spill crap in it yes. Would I do the same with a $68,000 ML or X5 NO CHANCE! I live in a completely different enviroment and I see Libby's (Cherokee's here), GC, Commanders, YJ, CJ etc running 90-120 mph all the time. I know for the longest time the older CJ was having issues with the FT4x4 and front diff's blowing out.
I understand completely the utilitarian issue on the 19" wheels, but given the area where I live, it is a practicle issue not a material issue. If I move back tot he US I will proably sell the wheels and tires to someone looking for something like that and go back to the 16" full time. I still have not made up my mind, I am only looking into it. Right now with rims and tires I am looking at $2200, so I am still "researching" to see if I really want to commit to this upgrade.
On a side note anyone using the SPAX adjustable dampeners? I saw Tire Rack had them. I really like adjustable dampeners.
BTW when I really want to have fun on the Autobahn I just take the race car from the garage and go have a little fun with Porsche's and Fararri's in the curves, they can't hang. Maybe when it warms up a little more I will finally get the KJ out on the Nuerburgring for a lap and video it. I hope I can break 10 min with it, Sabine did it in a Ford delivery van in 10:02!!!!
To me it still looks like you have two completely different uses you are trying to serve that would be best met with two different vehicles.
Taking a step back - the idea of trying to turn a Liberty into an autobahn runner... well... I don't think that one would have ever crossed my mind. To me it just seems kind of whacky.
I don't know anything about the Mercedes or BMW SUV's. I was just saying that some - at the very least - look like they are setup for highway driving and certainly look more appropriate for this use than a Liberty. I have to take your word for their shortcomings. However, I never thought the Liberty was particular adept at handling either. I've found that it wallows/leans too much in curves and also has a tendency to push. It’s definitely not the kind of precision instrument that I would want to be using to carve up some high speed roads.
I'm sure various Jeeps are driven on the autobahn all the time... But that doesn't necessarily mean that they should be (especially at those speeds). Sure that new Grand Cherokee SRT8 look like it might do for this duty, but some of the other run of the mill Jeeps you listed wouldn't be anywhere near the top of my list for such a job.
There comes a point when you can take that "do-it-all" idea for a vehicle too far. It's all about trade-offs and compromises. For what you gain in one department, you loose in another. The Liberty does great work at moderate off road work and routine commuting, but to do those things well you have to accept a compromise in handling.
If it were me, I would just as soon save that Liberty for the utility work that it's needed for and get me a different ride that is more suited for the autobahn commute to work.