Hey guys, I don't take anything personal, and I've provided as much info about my experiences with the Jeep as I can. Wherever that information leads, I'm also along for the ride.
Everyone has got me thinking and questioning my sanity on what I used, luckily I still had both bottles that I had used - I kept them as quart bottles to hold fresh Delvac in an easy-to-measure amount. Turns out, my memory was wrong. It wasn't the ZDDP additive, but it also wasn't the Rislone flush. This is the exact product I used - one quart per oil change, two oil changes in a row for 3k miles each:
http://barsproducts.com/catalog/view/2-engine-treatment-100qrMSDS for the same doesn't show anything important other than it is an oil. Surprise surprise.
Do I think it hurt the bearings? I honestly don't know. The top of the engine was clean and deposit-free when I tore it down, but the bottom was where both engines failed. Originally I had blamed the oil loss from the turbo failure on causing the damage to the bearings / rod / crankshaft... Now, with engine #2 never running low on oil or oil pressure... I am at a loss to point at anything specific other than a critical design flaw.
The cause of the engine starting to tap (Which I am guessing from other threads was the bearing tolerance starting to open up) was an "italian tune-up" WOT run from 45mph up to about 65, up the incline of the Talmadge Bridge here in Savannah. When I reached the top, I had an overboost code (Boost never exceeded 25psi, but that is also the alert point on the computer) and was in limp mode because of it. Rebooted the computer to clear the limp mode while coasting down the far side of the bridge, and started hearing the tapping soon after.
If the throttle cannot be floored in a mechanically stock vehicle without causing havoc, what does that say about the quality of the design? Yes, I had a GDE eco-tune in the computer... But the map was the same as everyone else that has the eco-tune, and Keith's programming of the turbo map is designed to increase safety while returning the economy that the engine should be capable of within its design.