gmctd wrote:
Cummins officially ok'd B5 for a while - now they've ok'd B20, it's on their website - but DCJ ain't budgin' - anything but LSD OR ULSD will seriously endanger your Diesel warranty, up to and incl voidance.
Apparently B5 up to B umpteen in your part of the country is not traceable to any same standard as the B's in my part of the country, or any part of the country - until the standard is strictly adhered to and enforced all over the country, that stuff could very well rotcher dipstick off, and worse - whatever the opinions, I'll wait till it's official - same goes for the ULSD situation - lubricity content is fully dependent on the distributor's adherence to strict rules covering how much and when - if he's running short, he ain't gonna hold up fuel deliveries while waiting for his supplier to come thru - adding ashless 2-stroke oil to my fuel is a safety hedge, and should also increase fuel mileage, but I suspect that the extra weight of the gallons that I carry serves to cancel out any gains.
Good comments.
It is indeed important to understand the fuel, know the differences between the various feedstocks, processing techniques and what that means for the properties of the fuel. For example, I often use Washington grown, Washington produced canola oil-based BD because it has better cold flow properties for winter. Since it is regionally produced and sold, it is also a more sustainable system. Also, I buy my fuel primarily from 2 sources extremely diligent in selling only ASTM D-6751 from NBAC audited facilities. I have been using B100 for the past 4 years with 0% problems. The consistency of performance for me may be due to using consistent suppliers (I buy in 800 gallon quantities for my own fuel depot) but the fact is, before using BD, quality of my regular diesel was quite variable by brand, by station, by storage and delivery technology and skill - things that are variable in all fuels.
Many people are not aware that official standards do now exists for BD similar to regular diesel. For regular diesel fuel, the
ASTM standard is ASTM D 975. All engine and fuel injection manufacturers design their engines around ASTM D 975. Early on in the biodiesel industry's development, engine manufacturers strongly encouraged the industry to develop an ASTM standard for biodiesel fuel which would allow them to provide their customers with a more definitive judgment on how the fuel would affect the engine and fuel system compared to ASTM D 975 fuel for which an engine was designed.
The biodiesel standard, ASTM PS 121-99, was approved and issued by ASTM in June of 1999. In December of 2001, ASTM approved the full standard for biodiesel, with the
new designation of D-6751. Biodiesel that meets the D-6751 specification has tens of millions miles of successful, real-world use.
Most of the mods discussed in this forum void warranty. It would be difficult to explain to a dealer why they should perform warranty work when you drive in with worn ball joints due to a Frankenlift, or tranny problems from a non-approved Suncoast torque converter, or exhaust problems due to elimination of the muffler or emissions control issues related to chipping or software alterations, or transmission failures to do increased torque from mods etc.. etc.. etc... These are all mods I will likely do myself, but I'm aware they will void aspects of my warranty and I am also aware that in total they create far more potential (and known) problems than using B100. It is certainly harder to hide these mods than to simply refill your tank with regular diesel if you ever had a problem. In short: Biodiesel is the least of your worries when it comes to doing anything with your CRD other than that which is described and approved of in the owner's manual.
The CRD comes with B5 from the factory and use of BD was part of their "green" advertising campaign. The car is officially approved for up to B20. Therefore, it is not a stretch to imagine that my ASTM-rated B100 from well-established, reputable NBAC audited facilities will probably not blow up my engine.
For the most part, people in this forum are curious tinkerers - the kind of people who explore possibilities, try new things and
lead the industry into new areas. The kind of thinkers I enjoy reading. My tinkering has been primarily in the area of biodiesel - I am now beginning to tinker with other systems via input, advice and experiences from the good folks in this forum. Tinkering always involves risk, but if we don't push the boundaries and lead, the status quo will remain and things of interest will rarely occur.
- Chris