I got a milemarker, because I have seen a lot of them used and very abused and never seen one fail yet (on HMMWV's and Deuce and ahalfs) All filled with mud and or sand, not maintained properly, and they worked flawlessly... Well except for a cable that snapped, but we were trying to pull out a 5 ton truck with a 9000lb winch
The only other winch I have ever seen in action was a warn (do not remember what model) and it free spooled fine, but would not pull at all. Its motor had gotten wet in an earlier water crossing, so I do not know if the connectors got wet or were corroded or what the issue was.