Go to your local auto upholsterer. Don't go to the brand new shiny place with all the speed goodies in the window. Find the little hole in the wall with the nearsighted, bent over old guy in the back room sitting in the haze of cigarette smoke with the gnarled up hands all stained from upholstery glue..... (uh, a little too descriptive?)
Seriously, find one of these old time guys and give him your console lid. He'll do whatever you want for it and probl. charge you under $50 (at most) cause he'll use a scrap of something he has lying around which is to small for anything else. Go in, chat him up, maybe bring him a brewski or 2 and you'll be amazed at the results!
I had a guy near me do one up for a Camaro some years ago and the thing was taller, cushier and used butter soft leather. Looked better than factory crap.
I had the same guy do a custom motorcycle seat cover in 3 different colors/types of vinyl (looked/felt like leather) including padding cut to my specs and he did the whole deal for around $200 when an aftermarket cover alone was about that much.
_________________
My pics!!'03 Rennie w/all Tupperware
Custom Roof Basket
Mopar Tubular Brush Guard
Garmin GPS V & Laptop w/Nav software
RAM products laptop mount
Maglite w/mount
Rear cargo bay tool cabinet
AllJs Rear Shelf
Rear receiver
250k miles!
LOST #CR051230