cgass wrote:
I've found the best way to decide on poles is to go try them out. There are so many different styles and features it's impossible to know what works for you until you give them a go.
I'm going to take it one step further. Before you can try them out, you need to know what questions to ask.
cgass wrote:
Personally, I stay away from the traditional twist lock style. I've had too many occurrences of them collapsing when you need them.
Those are the type of experiences that people need to hear. I've hiked with several people who use them, and while most have very little problems with collapsing, the twist lock poles do work themselves loose.
cgass wrote:
I also don't like shock ones. If I'm going to be putting my pole down I want it to stick, not bounce a little. It's unnerving to me. I know a lot of people who love them though because they aren't as hard on your elbows.
I borrowed my dad's poles with the suspension. I've spent years having my hands free, so having a pole in my hand seems cumbersome. I would use the poles for intermitted use, i.e., water crossings, maneuvering over rocks, etc.). But I can see how the “shock” would provide you with a false sense of security. You brought up a good point
cgass wrote:
My current poles are Black Diamond Ultra Distance Z Poles. They are the lightest, most compact, poles I could find when I bought them. They aren't adjustable however, so if you like to shorten/lengthen them for ascending/descending your options are limited. Plus side is there is no risk of collapse. They're a great pole for backpacking, but might be a little light, a pricey, for day hikes.
Great info.
I sure see a lot of poles at the REI scratch and dent sale. Most of them are missing the tips or have complaints about the shock absorbers and/or springs.