LibertyCRD wrote:
Well, I am getting close to 25,000 miles on my CRD now. I've run #2 diesel of questionable quality through it the entire time I've owned it. Been using 5W40 synthetic oil, servicing it regularly. And I took my intercooler hose off last week and found some oil in there but nothing major. Yes it was black in spots as I looked into the hose, but it was also orange in spots where there was no oil and the hose was clean. All in all there was certainly oil making its way into the intercooler...but it definitely was not running out of the hose when I pulled it off like some guys on here will lead you to believe. In fact, mine didn't scare me at all. Yes I suppose in a perfect world there would be no oil at all in that hose...but it's not that bad right now, ULSD fuel will make it better later this year, and I have a 100,000 mile warranty on the engine. So am I going to waste hundreds of dollars on a ProVent filter? Nope..don't think so. Old Navy's filter might go on my Jeep when it comes out if the price is right. But I'm not going to join the oil-in-intercooler-fear group. I think these engines are going to be OK.
"Lead you to believe"? There's no leading or believing about it my friend, I've seen firsthand what the intake system on a CRD looks like after 20K miles of running 0W40 oil. If you'd bothered looking, you could have found pics on this forum and others of how much oil was in the intake system after as few as 10K miles on vehicles that continued to use the factory 0W40 crap that passes for oil.
You gave your own answer as to why yours doesn't look that bad - you switched over to 5W40 oil with a decent API rating. There's an order of magnitude difference in the volatility rating (how much oil will boil off as vapor thru the CCV) between a 0W40 CF rated oil and a 5W40 CI-4 rated oil.
And it's not "hundreds of dollars", try $130. And what you call a fear group contains some experienced diesel owners that have seen this same setup and symptoms before on VW TDI's and know the problems it can lead to.