Elwenil wrote:
We have been discussing this on The Zone for a day or so. The media calls him a hero, I say he was a darn idiot. He was warned against taking that road and anyone who drives something like a Saab front wheel drive station wagon should know the limitations of their vehicle and not take a road it is not suited for. He made many bad choices and his family made the poor choice in trusting him. A classic case of some guy who lives a sheltered life in an office and has no clue what the real world is like. Natural Selection at it's best!
That is a little harsh, not too far off, but harsh. The mistakes that really killed him were made when he left home without extra food, cold weather clothes and weather info. Those are the mistakes that led to his demise. If he had prepared these, all the other little mistakes he made (taking a wrong turn in bad weather and getting stuck) would have been survivable. Anyone can get a car stuck and anyone can get lost. Perhaps another lesson to learn from this is do not trust technology-- otherwise sane and intelligent people will follow a d#$med GPS off the side of a cliff-- and he followed one thinking he was making a good decision-- probably that the gps would not route him on a road that was unsafe.
As for the mistakes he made after leaving his family, when you get lost and don't have food-- you do stupid things. No one can hold him accountable for being delirious and taking the wrong path after walking in the snow-- or taking his clothes off in the cold and leaving them. He had been without food for days and this non-nonsensical behavior is typical of people who are delirious with want of food/shelter/water.
The fact is he did do somethings right-- and his family is alive because of that. He at least made a fire, he rationed the food they did have, he melted snow for water, he rationed the gas trying to keep the family warm, he kept the cell phone with the family and had them repeatedly try to make contact with it and leave it on for prolonged periods of time. Knowing tech-- he knew they would probably be able to track the signal. He had the presence of mind to realize that the car was not going anywhere and that his situation was desperate enough that he should cannibalize the car and use its tires for a fire. Most people would not have been that smart-- and would have kept thinking of the wrecked car as transportation, refusing to part it up and use it for survival tools.
If he had just had more food and better clothes, this situation would have turned out far different, as he would have been able to think clearer and would have stayed in the car longer or followed the road should he have elected to leave the car.
But before we call him an idiot-- realize that 98% of the population are in the same situation every time they travel-- they have done nothing to prepare for an event like this. If most people were caught in this situation, the end result would have likely been the same or worse. So I guess idiocy loves company as much as misery does.