Murphyman wrote:
Colts are the better team, by far actually. However football is never predictable, and the Saints came out on top. It's a good win for the club. Will they be back next year? Who knows...
I don't want to start a flame war with you Murph - you are the OP on this thread, beloved by all - but I have to disagree. I think (trying to seperate my bias from my fanhood) that the Saints, top-to-bottom, are a better team, but only
slightly. It was enough to give them the 14 point edge last night. Here's how I break it down, based on team advantage:
QB: Advantage Colts, but not by much. Manning may only have the edge due to physical characteristics (much taller and bigger in the pocket, stronger arm). I think Brees has better poise than Manning and doesn't get frustrated as easily. Both Manning and Brees are brilliant at reading defenses and delivering the ball - as evidenced by their numbers last night.
RB: Advantage Saints, but not by much. My LSU homie Addai had a good game last night, so did the rookie behind him. But the Saints' stable is deeper, and they are all such a receiving threat out of the backfield.
WR: Even. Experience and depth, playmaking ability, and physical characteristics on both teams are nearly the same. Trade the receivers from one team to the other and it wouldn't look much different.
TE: Advantage Colts. Shockey and Thomas are both great, but Clark is a BEAST.
OLine: Advantage Saints. They are bigger and stronger, and pushed the Colts D Line around all night. If Freeney had been 100%, he would have been doubled or chipped all night, and the Saints still would have had the advantage. They've protected Brees all year, and beat the Minnesota DLine (arguably the NFL's best) handily both in pass protection and run blocking. The big guys did the same last night.
DLine: Advantage Colts, but only in comparison to the Saints D-Line, for reasons stated above.
Linebackers: Advantage Saints. Athletic, quick, and hard-hitting linebackers are the core of the Saints defense. Jonathan Vilma is brilliant at quarterbacking the defense, and showed it last night with disrupting the pass play to Collie. How many middle linebackers could have recognized the play like that, then got back in coverage to knock it away? Junior Seau comes to mind. . .
Secondary: Advantage Saints, but barely. The right balance of age and youthful athleticism. If Bob Sanders had been in, things may have been a lot different. I think he is the heart of the Colts secondary like Vilma is the heart of the Saints defense.
Special Teams: Advantage Saints, but only due to the signing of Matt Stover as the Colts FG kicker. Other aspects of special teams are dead even.
My point is this: these teams were very, very, evenly matched coming in. I don't think that either team was
clearly "better" than the other, and both beat some of the best teams in the NFL to get to that game. The small, marginal advantages that the Saints enjoyed ended up playing directly into Indy's weaknesses, and led to the win.
With Indy, if a defense can pull the magic rabbit out of their hat and actually disrupt Peyton Manning, they will win. He is the key to Indy winning or losing. If the Saints D had not started creeping up on his patterns and reads, he wouldn't have started missing throws - which led to him staring down Reggie Wayne on the interception. Just my

_________________
In this war of lines, so many have been crossed. Where will it all stop?
2006 Deep Beryl Green CRD Sport
*SOLD 1/22/12*Provent, V6 Airbox, Fumoto, Samcos, GDE ECO & TCM Tune, Euro JK TC, Magnaflow Catback
245/70/16 Destination A/T's
Boiler's Radiator Skid PlateJeepin' By Al 2.5 inch Adjust-A-Strut Lift, JBA Gen 4.5 UCA's (6/5/10)
