I recently needed to replace my five year old Sears P1 AGM battery. The best replacement I found is the X2 Power SLI34-78AGMDP sold by Batteries Plus:
https://www.batteriesplus.com/battery/c ... 34=78agmdp It is an AGM type, 880 CCA, five year warranty, and currently 10% off. It includes side terminals which might be useful for connecting accessories. It is manufactured by Northstar which looks to have a good reputation. The bright blue top looks good too!
I am getting much improved cold starts now.