WWDiesel wrote:
timothyd wrote:
The bushing was readily available so I ordered that for now, but that diagram is a bit confusing, is it just suggesting that the bearing can replace the bushing? Or that both are used?
I believe either can be used, your choice, that is why it shows two part numbers for the same part location on the diagram.
Bearings are usually a better choice over bushings on rotating parts.
yes, 'usually'.
Me personally. would stay WITH the bushing if building a swamper/mudder/off road/ (and in my case TALL GRASS) type vehicle. Grass has killed more seals on my equipment than anything. It wraps around anything that rotates, and cuts. boy, does it cut!! Next thing you know, dirt and water has a path in.
yes, the skid pan should help a lot here..
Bushings are a lot more 'forgiving' than a extremely hardened roller.. Water and dirt will blow one out in no time. I'd rather have bits of phenolic plastic in the differential than remnants of bombed out needle bearings.
Look, road splash seems to be worse on the front end, my guess is that front axle is 'cutting trail' in snow, mud, rain.... and there is more flying debris/water than the rear axle see's because it benefits from a 'premade' trail by the fronts.
So, if you are using the Jeep mainly on clean, hard roads, those rollers will probably outlast the bushing 2 to 1, or more.
With the bushing, run em until the seal give way.. and you see leaks. You have some 'time' to fix it..
Time on the other hand isn't so nice to precision needles, especially when subjected to water and dirt.
So, like anything, there are pro's and con's. Bushings triumph in the dirt. But kept clean, rollers outlast.
one last consideration; Bushings can be sacrificial. This is good. A worn bushing and seal usually wont destroy whatever is riding in it.. the intermediate shafts for example. Those 'grooves' on the ID part of the bushing make a great place for foreign material to collect, and kept away from chewing directly on the shaft.
Not the case with the needle bearing. There is NO room for 1 tiny crumb.