Reflex wrote:
I don't really feel any resentment over gas taxes, and would like it if it just moved to a mileage/weight tax. Of all the taxes I complain about, fuel taxes is lowest on my list. It just makes sense, its a direct usage tax. It allows someone to choose to avoid the road taxes by simply not driving, and thats fair. I know I'd be pissed if I commutted via light rail or bicycle every day and I was still stuck paying for the roads/highways/etc.
In Charlotte/Mecklenburg county, they have the opposite situation right now. They're trying to start off a light rail system, which from what I've seen is poorly designed and conceived, will only have 3 rail cars and at best be able to carry only a few hundred passengers each day, northern stations are nowhere near where the majority of commuters are located and little if any available planned parking for those that do decide to ride, is already well past being 100% over budget and none of the hardware is even on order yet.
The local government's answer to paying for it is to impose a county wide sales tax. People are taking a view similar to yours on fuel taxes - they're not in the position of ever being able to use the light rail system but are still being asked to pay for it. They've already circulated a petition to get a motion put on the Nov ballot to repeal the sales tax, and last word was they already had more than enough signatures to do so.
It might seem shortsighted to not at least start a light rail system, but you'd have to understand what's happened with Charlotte local government over the past 10 years. They've spent hundreds of millions on such projects as a basketball arena and a NASCAR Hall of Fame, and now talking of a baseball stadium, even after voters rejected using public funds for such projects in nonbinding referendums, meanwhile their school system and public services goes begging for money. A lot of longtime residents in Charlotte have decided that they're not paying for another boondoggle.