So I removed the tire carrier from the swing gate. And Tom's lock bolt trick to getting those torx bolts out didn't work. So I went up to Advance Auto Parts and the guys there took a look at it. A 250 pound man just put some vice grips on the first two bolts and broke them loose. Then he used the external torx socet for the third and fourth bolts. The head snapped off of the fourth one, so after fiddling around with that for 5 minutes we were finally able to break it loose.
After it was all said and done the swing gate looked like poo.

So today I ran up to O'Reily and spend $45 on Mothers Back 2 Black, Mothers Clay Bar Kit, Mothers Carnauba Wax, 2 microfiber pads, and 2 terry cloth pads.
Used the back to black on the handle and small plastic handle on the rear window.
I used the other products on the swing gate and well...

Before

After

Before

After

The only reason I'm not pleased with the outcome is there is a faint line and some dents where the tire carrier used to be but...
After I get back from Big Rock this coming weekend I'll use this stuff on the entire Jeep. Hoosier Jeeper style.

I'm excited to see how it turns out.
Still working on the tire carrier for the roof. Should be done soon!