MrMopar64 wrote:
A metallic plug operates at a different temperature limit than a ceramic one, so the answer to all of your three statements of quick/smooth starting, damage, and compatibility all revolve around if they're operating at the proper temperature and the capability of the "existing" ECU calibration to operate them at such.
What most owners don't realize is that if these metallic plugs operate too hot with the existing cal, then you'll suffer issues 2 and 3 in your list. If the glow plugs are too cold, you'll face issue 1 and 3 in your list.
I will wait to reserve judgement on the statement about "tests according to engine OEM testing protocols" until I see a picture of a glow plug instrumented with a thermocouple and the validation of the temperature at all ambient conditions, and ran some many hrs of durability test in an engine.
Look at it this way, Etecno1 have been designing and manufacturing glow plugs for 30 years. Given the choice between them and Chrysler to provide the best solution for our engine I know where my money will go.
Glend wrote:
This is not a case of getting a free set of plugs. I have had no problems with the original equipment ones and could just sit and watch.
I am happy to install and test them in this environment, once I know they are not going to strip the treads or hit the cylinders - which now seems to be confirmed.
You missed my point. Etecno were looking for
serious volunteers to test these plugs and were overwhelmed with offers. Part of being a tester is, indeed, taking the risk that they will strip, hit the cylinders or even fall apart in your engine. A set of calipers and thread gauges, however, will tell you that the first two will not happen. If you're not prepared to take this risk you should have let one of the other many volunteers have this opportunity.
I'm sure that there are owners out there that do currently have problems with the OE plugs, can't get replacement ceramic, don't wish to go down the Chrysler "bodge-n-patch" route and would have been more than willing to install these plugs immediately.
If everybody approached it with this skepticism then the plugs would never get tested and, let's face it, the sooner they get validated the better for all of us.