ThunderbirdJunkie wrote:
Stupid question...
are 8.25s really that hit-and-miss? I'm terrible at axle maintenance (meaning I don't do it, don't ever check the level, and I'm pretty sure there's water in mine right now) and I've never heard a peep out of either diff...
And then you have somebody fanatical about maintenance, and they've got a bearing going out.
Am I missing something?
I think you have a good argument on your hands. Josh at Crane Hi Clearance and I had this same discussion. Being around work trucks my whole life, I’ve seen rear ends go out due to high heat and lack of maintenance (neglect). This is one reason why those who have trucks and tow large loads take differential maintenance into consideration. That’s why my Mag-Hytec rear diff on my Dodge Cummins comes in a aluminum housing with cooling fins and a magnetic drain plug and dipstick. That seems overkill, but when you’re towing serious loads for lots of miles, then the rear diff can not (under any circumstances) become neglected. However, as Josh pointed out, our Jeeps do not take the abuse, weight extremes, and high heat temperatures like our big trucks do. Therefore, his argument states that we do not need fancy diff covers with extra cooling capacity and magnetic drain plugs. He does recommend changing the diff fluid as recommended by the owners manual, but he isn’t an overkill type of guy. Josh mentioned that he’s taken apart many factory diff covers in his time. Some differentials had never been cracked open with well over 100,000 miles on them and the parts looked fairly good besides the burned up oil (which in some cases has turned into sludge). The fact of the matter is this: There is no debate on whether or not changing the diff fluid is beneficial. However, if you’re planning on trading it in after 75,000 - 100,00 miles, then why do the maintenance? If you plan on keeping your vehicle for over 100,000 + miles, then Yes, maintenance will pay off. I was hoping that ARB would make a diff cover for the KJ because I prefer the magnetic drain plug and dip stick, whereas Josh would say, “That’s not necessary on a Jeep.” This is where Josh and I would disagree, I would much rather have a drain plug and a dip stick so I wouldn’t have to crack open my rear diff every time I want to change the fluid. Plus, the magnetic drain plug and dip stick allows me to monitor the wear factor on the gears. But hey, I’m overkill, and that’s okay, because I’m keeping my Jeep well beyond the 300,000 mile mark………………………